7 minute read
Facility Recources

Guide: How to Fix Healthcare Staffing Shortages

Written by
Jillian Renken
Published on
February 18, 2026
TL;DR
Healthcare staffing shortages in 2026 stem from converging factors: turnover exceeding 22% for nurses and 8% for physicians, seasonal demand fluctuations, service line expansions, and structural physician shortages. Effective stabilization strategies combine three approaches matched to specific needs. Internal recruiting builds long-term stability but requires 60-90 days, making it unsuitable for urgent coverage. Locum tenens deploys physicians and APPs within 5-10 days for emergency gaps, seasonal surge, and service transitions at 1.5-2.0x base costs, justified when preventing revenue loss and burnout. Advanced practice provider expansion addresses physician shortages through team-based care models, with NPs and PAs managing appropriate clinical scenarios. Balanced budget allocation: 70% internal recruiting for permanent positions, 8% locum tenens for immediate coverage, 12% APP development, and 10% premium overtime. Implementation requires phased approach: stop bleeding with temporary coverage (weeks 1-4), stabilize operations through priority recruitment (months 2-4), build strategic capability with APP teams and retention programs (months 5-12), then sustain continuous improvement. Partner with specialized healthcare recruiters for physician searches, high-volume needs, and specialized roles to prevent HR team overload. Track leading indicators (time-to-fill, pipeline health), lagging indicators (vacancy rate, turnover, premium labor costs), and quality metrics (retention, engagement, safety) to ensure strategy effectiveness.

Guide: How to Fix Healthcare Staffing Shortages

Healthcare staffing shortages continue to challenge facility administrators throughout 2026, creating operational pressure that affects patient care, staff morale, and financial performance. The American Hospital Association reports that 83% of hospitals face more acute workforce gaps compared to three years ago, with the shortage now extending beyond nursing to physicians, advanced practice providers, and allied health professionals across nearly every specialty.

What separates 2026 from previous years is the convergence of multiple workforce pressures occurring simultaneously. Facilities aren't just replacing departing staff, they're managing seasonal demand spikes, expanding service lines to remain competitive, and filling critical physician gaps that internal HR teams lack bandwidth to address. Traditional recruitment approaches that worked in 2019 now require 75% longer timelines while delivering fewer qualified candidates.

This guide examines the root causes driving current shortages and provides a structured framework for stabilizing coverage without overwhelming your internal teams. We'll compare three primary strategies, internal recruiting, locum tenens coverage, and advanced practice provider deployment, helping you match the right approach to your facility's specific constraints and objectives.

Root Causes of Healthcare Staffing Shortages in 2026

Understanding why positions remain unfilled helps facilities address the right problems rather than applying generic solutions. Healthcare workforce challenges stem from four interconnected causes that require different mitigation strategies.

1. Accelerated Turnover Rates

Voluntary turnover has reached unprecedented levels across healthcare roles. NSI Nursing Solutions' 2026 Healthcare Retention Report shows registered nurse turnover averaging 22.7%, up from 18.7% in 2021. Physician turnover has climbed to 8.4% annually, with specialists in high-stress areas like emergency medicine and hospitality medicine experiencing rates above 12%.

The financial impact is substantial. Each departing RN costs facilities between $46,000 and $64,000 when accounting for recruitment, onboarding, productivity ramp, and overtime coverage during vacancies. For physicians, replacement costs range from $500,000 to $1.2 million depending on specialty and market competitiveness.

Primary turnover drivers in 2026:

  • Burnout from sustained high patient volumes and administrative burden
  • Insufficient compensation growth relative to inflation and market movement
  • Limited career advancement opportunities in smaller facilities
  • Inflexible scheduling incompatible with work-life integration
  • Inadequate support staff leading to professionals performing tasks below their skill level
  • Better opportunities with competitors offering sign-on bonuses and enhanced benefits

Facilities experiencing turnover above 18% for nurses or 7% for physicians should treat retention as urgent strategic priority rather than accepting losses as inevitable.

2. Seasonal Demand Fluctuations

Healthcare demand follows predictable seasonal patterns that create temporary but intense staffing pressure. Winter respiratory illness season from November through March drives 30-40% volume increases in emergency departments and medical-surgical units. Summer trauma season brings corresponding spikes to surgical services and intensive care.

These patterns aren't new, but 2026 brings compounding factors. Influenza, RSV, and COVID variants now circulate simultaneously during winter months, creating longer and more severe surge periods. Facilities that once managed seasonal demand through moderate overtime now face sustained periods requiring significant additional capacity.

Key seasonal challenges:

  • Difficulty projecting exact timing and magnitude of surges
  • Insufficient lead time to hire and onboard permanent staff before peak demand
  • Existing staff burnout from excessive overtime during surge periods
  • Competition among facilities for the same limited temporary workforce
  • Budget pressures when seasonal hiring extends longer than anticipated

A structured approach to seasonal staffing plans recruitment activities 4-6 months before anticipated surges rather than reacting when vacancies become critical.

3. Service Line Expansion Requirements

Facilities expand services to capture market share, improve care coordination, and respond to community needs. Cardiology programs add structural heart services, orthopedic departments implement robotic surgery platforms, and primary care networks open urgent care satellites. Each expansion requires specialized professionals often in short supply.

The challenge intensifies because expansion timing is unpredictable. Capital equipment arrives, credentialing completes, or competitor actions force accelerated timelines. Internal HR teams already managing baseline turnover lack capacity to simultaneously recruit for multiple new service lines while maintaining quality hiring standards.

Expansion staffing complications:

  • Specialized skills with limited candidate pools
  • Competition with established programs offering higher compensation
  • New services requiring multiple complementary roles hired in coordination
  • Revenue targets dependent on rapid staffing and productivity ramp
  • Risk of service launch delays damaging facility reputation

Facilities planning significant expansions should engage specialized healthcare recruiters 9-12 months before anticipated launch dates to build candidate pipelines before urgent need arises.

4. Physician and Provider Gaps

The Association of American Medical Colleges projects physician shortages will reach 86,000 by 2036, with particular gaps in primary care, psychiatry, and rural markets. However, 2026 presents immediate challenges as early pandemic-era retirements removed experienced physicians from practice before planned succession.

Unlike nursing shortages addressed through accelerated education programs, physician pipeline constraints are structural. Medical school enrollment and residency positions increase slowly, creating multi-year lag between demand recognition and supply response. Facilities cannot simply "recruit harder" when insufficient candidates exist in the market.

Physician shortage characteristics in 2026:

  • Primary care physicians leaving independent practice for employed positions with larger systems
  • Specialists concentrated in urban and suburban markets avoiding rural and underserved areas
  • Hospitalists and emergency physicians experiencing highest turnover due to demanding schedules
  • Older physicians retiring earlier than projected due to burnout and regulatory burden
  • International medical graduates facing visa and credentialing timeline extensions

These gaps require different solutions than nurse staffing challenges, often involving care model redesign and advanced practice provider integration rather than traditional recruitment.

Healthcare staffing shortages in 2026 result from four converging factors: accelerated turnover exceeding 22% for nurses and 8% for physicians, seasonal demand fluctuations driving 30-40% volume increases, service line expansions requiring specialized skills, and structural physician shortages projected at 86,000 by 2036. Facilities need differentiated strategies for each cause rather than generic recruitment efforts.

Strategy 1: Internal Recruiting Optimization

Internal recruiting, hiring professionals directly onto facility payroll, remains the foundation of sustainable workforce planning. However, 2026 market conditions require optimization beyond traditional job posting and interview processes.

Current State of Internal Recruiting

Healthcare facilities average 89 days from requisition approval to candidate acceptance for specialized clinical roles, with critical care, perioperative, and imaging positions often exceeding 120 days. During this extended timeline, patient care demands continue while existing staff absorb additional workload through overtime.

The Bureau of Labor Statistics reports healthcare job openings outnumber available candidates 1.8 to 1, meaning facilities compete intensely for limited talent. Traditional advantages—geographic preference, mission-driven culture, work-life balance, matter less when candidates receive multiple competing offers with sign-on bonuses reaching $30,000-$50,000 for experienced nurses and $50,000-$100,000 for physicians.

Internal Recruiting Best Practices for 2026

1. Accelerate Decision-Making Timelines
Candidates accept positions elsewhere while facilities complete extended interview processes. Reduce time-to-offer by:

  • Consolidating interview rounds from 3-4 separate days to 1-2 intensive sessions
  • Empowering hiring managers to extend offers without multiple approval layers
  • Using video interviews for initial screening to expand candidate reach
  • Making competitive offers immediately rather than waiting for candidate negotiations

2. Enhance Employer Value Proposition
Differentiation matters in competitive markets. Communicate specific advantages beyond compensation:

  • Schedule flexibility including self-scheduling and compressed workweeks
  • Professional development budgets and specialty training support
  • Student loan repayment assistance leveraging federal and state programs
  • Career advancement pathways with clear progression timelines
  • Technology investments reducing administrative burden
  • Supportive leadership and healthy workplace culture

3. Leverage Employee Referral Programs
Your existing staff understands your culture and maintains professional networks. Effective referral programs include:

  • Meaningful incentives ($3,000-$8,000 per successful hire in critical roles)
  • Tiered payments encouraging referral quality (partial payment at hire, remainder after retention milestone)
  • Recognition beyond financial rewards for prolific referrers
  • Simplified referral process through mobile-friendly platforms
  • Regular communication about priority openings and candidate profiles

4. Build Passive Candidate Pipelines
Top performers aren't actively job searching. Relationship-based recruiting develops connections before immediate need:

  • Participation in professional conferences and continuing education events
  • Social media presence on LinkedIn and specialty-specific platforms
  • Email nurture campaigns for professionals who previously expressed interest
  • Alumni networks for professionals with prior facility connections
  • Community engagement creating positive brand awareness

Internal Recruiting Limitations

Despite optimization, internal recruiting cannot solve immediate coverage needs. Facilities requiring staff within 30 days while maintaining quality standards should combine internal recruiting for long-term stability with faster deployment models for urgent gaps.

Where internal recruiting struggles:

  • Emergency coverage when positions become vacant unexpectedly
  • Seasonal surge staffing requiring temporary capacity increases
  • Specialized roles with extremely limited candidate pools
  • Geographic markets with insufficient local talent
  • Situations requiring immediate coverage while conducting thorough evaluation

For these scenarios, facilities need complementary strategies that deploy faster while internal recruiting builds sustainable workforce foundation.

Strategy 2: Locum Tenens Coverage

Locum tenens staffing places physicians and advanced practice providers in temporary assignments ranging from weeks to months, providing rapid deployment when internal recruiting cannot meet urgent needs. This model has become essential infrastructure for healthcare facilities rather than emergency backup plan.

How Locum Tenens Works in 2026

Facilities partner with specialized staffing firms maintaining networks of physicians and APPs seeking assignment variety, geographic flexibility, or supplemental income. When a need arises, sudden resignation, extended medical leave, seasonal surge, the facility submits requirements and the firm presents qualified candidates, often within 5-10 days.

The locum professional works on-site (or sometimes via telemedicine) under temporary contract terms. The staffing firm handles credentialing coordination, travel arrangements, housing, and administrative support. Facilities pay a daily or hourly rate that includes the professional's compensation plus agency fee, typically 1.5-2.0x what equivalent base salary would cost.

Strategic Applications for Locum Tenens

Emergency Coverage Situations:

  • Unexpected physician resignations creating immediate coverage gaps
  • Medical or family leave extending beyond what per diem or existing staff can absorb
  • Credential verification delays for accepted permanent hires
  • Multiple simultaneous vacancies exceeding internal capacity to cover

Seasonal Demand Management:

  • Winter respiratory illness surge requiring additional hospitalists and emergency physicians
  • Summer trauma season needing supplemental surgical and critical care specialists
  • Vacation coverage allowing permanent staff predictable time off without service reductions
  • Special event coverage for facilities in tourist or seasonal population areas

Service Line Transitions:

  • Bridge coverage while recruiting permanent providers for new service lines
  • Temporary capacity while assessing sustainable long-term demand
  • Specialized procedures or consultations not requiring full-time presence
  • Program coverage during leadership transitions or restructuring

Locum Tenens Implementation Framework
Successful locum tenens utilization requires structured processes:

1. Vendor Selection and Relationship Management
Partner with 2-3 specialized locum tenens firms rather than constantly switching based solely on rate:

  • Firms understanding your facility culture and community characteristics
  • Track record of rapid response and candidate quality
  • Robust credentialing support reducing deployment delays
  • Transparent pricing without hidden fees
  • Account management providing proactive communication

2. Integration Protocols
Temporary physicians perform best when welcomed and supported:

  • Pre-arrival information packets covering systems, protocols, and community resources
  • Designated liaison coordinating housing, hospital access, and schedule questions
  • Clinical orientation covering facility-specific procedures and documentation
  • Regular check-ins during initial weeks addressing concerns before they escalate
  • Feedback mechanisms allowing continuous improvement

3. Financial Planning
Budget for locum tenens as strategic coverage tool rather than emergency expense:

  • Allocate 5-10% of physician labor budget for locum tenens coverage
  • Track total costs including avoided revenue loss and overtime reduction
  • Monitor market rates by specialty for negotiation leverage
  • Evaluate volume commit discounts with preferred vendors

4. Transition Planning
Treat locum tenens as bridge to permanent solutions:

  • Maintain aggressive permanent recruitment during locum coverage
  • Evaluate locum performance for potential permanent conversion
  • Knowledge transfer from departing locum to incoming permanent provider
  • Patient and referring physician communication about transition

Locum tenens staffing deploys physicians and advanced practice providers within 5-10 days for temporary coverage, costing 1.5-2.0x base salary rates but preventing revenue loss from service disruptions. Best used for emergency coverage, seasonal demand, and service line transitions while conducting permanent recruitment. Facilities should budget 5-10% of physician labor costs for strategic locum coverage rather than treating it as emergency expense.

Strategy 3: Advanced Practice Provider Expansion

Advanced practice providers, represent one of healthcare's fastest-growing workforce segments. Strategic APP deployment addresses physician shortages while improving care access and team-based service delivery.

The APP Growth Trajectory in 2026

The American Association of Nurse Practitioners reports 385,000 licensed NPs in the United States, up from 290,000 in 2020. Physician assistant programs graduated 12,800 new PAs in 2025, contributing to a workforce exceeding 170,000 practitioners. Both professions continue expanding as healthcare systems recognize APPs' value in high-quality, cost-effective care delivery.

Research published in JAMA demonstrates equivalent patient outcomes for APPs and physicians in appropriate clinical contexts, particularly in primary care, chronic disease management, and hospital medicine settings. This evidence base supports expanded APP utilization beyond traditional physician supervision models.

APP Practice Authority by State
APP practice independence varies significantly by state, affecting recruitment and deployment strategies. As of 2026:

Full Practice Authority States (24 states):

  • NPs can evaluate, diagnose, prescribe, and treat without physician oversight
  • Typically requires 2-4 years supervised practice before independent practice
  • Examples: Arizona, Colorado, Connecticut, Hawaii, Maryland, Minnesota, Nevada, New Mexico, Oregon, Washington

Reduced Practice Authority States (15 states):

  • NPs have some independence but require collaborative agreements
  • Physician involvement in protocols but not direct supervision
  • Examples: Alabama, California, Georgia, Illinois, Michigan, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Texas

Restricted Practice Authority States (11 states):

  • NPs require physician supervision and oversight
  • Physician must review charts and co-sign documentation
  • Examples: Arkansas, Florida, Missouri, North Carolina, Oklahoma, South Carolina

Facilities in full practice states have greater strategic flexibility for APP deployment, while those in restricted states must structure physician collaboration agreements adding recruitment complexity.

Strategic APP Deployment Models

Primary Care Enhancement:
APPs manage chronic conditions, preventive care, and acute minor illnesses, allowing physicians to focus on complex patients. Common structures include:

  • APP-led panels for established patients with periodic physician oversight
  • Shared panels where APP and physician coordinate care for complex populations
  • APP-only clinics for preventive services, immunizations, and minor acute care
  • Telemedicine services staffed by APPs expanding geographic access

Hospital Medicine Teams:
APPs round on admitted patients, coordinate care transitions, and manage routine complications. Implementation approaches:

  • APP-physician pairs covering service together with role differentiation
  • APP-led teams for lower-acuity patients with physician backup
  • Night coverage by APPs with daytime physician oversight
  • Procedure teams where APPs perform procedures under supervision

Specialty Service Support:
APPs extend specialist capacity through defined clinical protocols:

  • Orthopedic surgery APPs managing post-operative care and minor procedures
  • Cardiology APPs conducting consultations and managing stable conditions
  • Gastroenterology APPs performing endoscopy and colonoscopy procedures
  • Oncology APPs coordinating chemotherapy and managing treatment side effects

APP Recruitment Considerations
While APP supply exceeds physician availability, recruitment still requires strategic approach:

Compensation and Benefits:

  • Base salary for experienced NPs: $110,000-$135,000 depending on specialty and geography
  • Base salary for experienced PAs: $115,000-$140,000 with similar variation
  • Sign-on bonuses of $10,000-$25,000 increasingly common in competitive markets
  • Continuing education support and professional development budgets
  • Malpractice insurance coverage and tail coverage for departures

Practice Environment:

  • Collaborative relationships with physicians supporting rather than limiting practice
  • Autonomy appropriate to experience level and state practice authority
  • Administrative support reducing documentation burden
  • Clear career advancement pathways and specialization opportunities
  • Healthy work-life balance with reasonable patient volumes and call schedules

Geographic and Cultural Factors:

  • Community characteristics and lifestyle amenities
  • Spouse/partner employment opportunities in two-career households
  • School quality for families with children
  • Cost of living relative to compensation
  • Community diversity and inclusion

APP vs. Physician Decision Framework
Determine when APP deployment addresses needs and when physician recruitment remains essential:

Clinical Scenario Best Staffing Approach Reasoning
Primary care chronic disease management APP-led with physician consultation Evidence supports equivalent outcomes, cost-effective
Complex multi-system illness Physician-led with APP support Diagnostic complexity benefits from physician training
Routine procedures (endoscopy, joint injections) APP after training and credentialing Procedure competency regardless of degree, frees physician time
Hospital admissions and discharges Shared APP-physician model APP manages routine, physician handles complex
Emergency department minor care APP-staffed fast track Efficient resource utilization, physician focuses on critical cases
Subspecialty consultation Physician with APP follow-up Initial assessment requires specialist expertise

The optimal model frequently combines physicians and APPs in complementary roles rather than simple substitution, improving team efficiency while maintaining quality.

APP Program Implementation Roadmap
Facilities without established APP workforce should phase implementation:

Phase 1: Planning and Foundation (Months 1-3)

  1. Assess clinical areas with highest physician shortage impact
  2. Evaluate state practice authority and required collaboration structures
  3. Develop job descriptions, compensation ranges, and reporting relationships
  4. Create clinical protocols and physician supervision frameworks where required
  5. Establish credentialing and privileging processes for APPs

Phase 2: Initial Recruitment (Months 4-6)

  1. Launch recruitment for 2-3 APP positions in highest priority areas
  2. Engage contract staffing partners to supplement internal recruiting
  3. Develop onboarding program including clinical orientation and mentorship
  4. Train physicians and staff on collaborative practice expectations
  5. Implement documentation and workflow systems

Phase 3: Deployment and Optimization (Months 7-12)

  1. Deploy initial APP cohort with intensive support and oversight
  2. Monitor productivity, quality metrics, and patient satisfaction
  3. Refine protocols and workflows based on performance data
  4. Address challenges and barriers identified by APP and physician staff
  5. Plan expansion based on demonstrated value and organizational capacity

Phase 4: Sustained Growth (Year 2+)

  1. Expand APP positions in successful deployment areas
  2. Extend model to additional clinical areas based on Phase 1 results
  3. Develop APP leadership positions and career advancement pathways
  4. Create APP-specific continuing education and professional development
  5. Benchmark APP productivity and outcomes against national standards

Integrated Staffing Strategy Framework

The most effective approach combines multiple strategies matched to specific situations rather than relying exclusively on one model. This framework helps facilities allocate resources across internal recruiting, locum tenens, and APP deployment.

Strategic Matrix for Staffing Decisions

Need Characteristics Primary Strategy Secondary Strategy Timeline Expectation
Immediate physician gap (0-30 days) Locum tenens Internal recruiting begins Coverage within 1-2 weeks
Seasonal surge (known 3-6 months ahead) Contract staffing + APP deployment Internal recruiting for permanent Staffing before surge begins
Service line expansion APP deployment + targeted physician recruitment Locum tenens bridge if needed 6-12 months to full capacity
Primary care access gap APP-led model with physician oversight Physician recruitment for complex care 3-6 months to launch
High physician turnover area Retention initiatives + APP team model Locum tenens for transitions Ongoing improvement focus
Rural physician shortage Hybrid: Locum + telemedicine + APP Recruitment with enhanced incentives Sustained multi-year effort

Resource Allocation Guidelines
Facilities with limited HR bandwidth should allocate recruitment effort based on impact and probability of success:

High Priority Internal Recruiting:

  • Positions with strong local candidate pools
  • Roles where facility offers competitive compensation and benefits
  • Specialties with reasonable time-to-fill (under 90 days)
  • Situations where candidate quality evaluation requires extensive vetting

Outsource or Use Locum Tenens:

  • Emergency coverage needs (under 30 days)
  • Highly specialized roles with national candidate pools
  • Positions requiring extensive search beyond local market
  • Temporary or seasonal capacity increases

APP Development Focus:

  • Clinical areas with physician shortage and appropriate APP scope
  • Services where APP deployment improves access and efficiency
  • Opportunities to enhance team-based care delivery
  • Markets where APP compensation is competitive advantage

This allocation prevents internal HR teams from spreading effort across too many competing priorities while ensuring coverage gaps receive appropriate attention.

Effective healthcare staffing strategies combine internal recruiting for long-term stability (70% of budget), locum tenens for immediate physician coverage (8%), APP deployment for physician shortage mitigation (12%), and premium overtime for short-term gaps (10%). Match strategy to need characteristics: locum tenens for emergency coverage, APP development for primary care and hospital medicine, internal recruiting for roles with strong candidate pools. This diversification prevents HR team overload while ensuring coverage.

Stabilizing Coverage Without Overloading HR Teams

Small to mid-sized facilities often lack HR bandwidth to simultaneously manage baseline recruitment, address urgent vacancies, and develop new staffing models. This section provides practical approaches to stabilize coverage while respecting resource constraints.

Workload Assessment and Prioritization
Begin by understanding current HR capacity and commitments:

Current State Analysis:

  1. Document time spent on each recruitment activity (sourcing, screening, interviews, offers, onboarding)
  2. Identify positions in active recruitment and time in process
  3. Calculate average time-to-fill by role type
  4. Assess quality of recent hires and retention rates
  5. Survey hiring managers on recruitment satisfaction and pain points

Prioritization Framework:Apply these criteria to determine which positions warrant internal HR focus versus outsourcing:

  • Business criticality: Impact on patient care and revenue if unfilled
  • Probability of success: Local candidate pool strength and compensation competitiveness
  • Time sensitivity: How quickly position must be filled
  • Evaluation complexity: Difficulty assessing candidate quality and cultural fit
  • HR bandwidth availability: Team capacity to manage recruitment effectively

Positions scoring high on business criticality but low on probability of success or HR bandwidth make ideal candidates for external recruiting support.

Engaging Healthcare Recruiting Partners
Specialized healthcare recruiters can extend HR capacity without adding permanent headcount. Effective partnership requires clear role definition and performance expectations.

When to Engage External Recruiters:

  • Physician and advanced practice provider searches requiring national candidate reach
  • High-volume seasonal staffing needs exceeding internal capacity
  • Specialized roles with limited candidate pools
  • Geographic markets outside your natural recruiting reach
  • Situations requiring urgent fill while maintaining quality standards

Partnership Structure Options:
Contingency Recruiting:
Pay only when hire is made, typically 20-25% of first-year compensation. Best for roles with reasonable candidate availability where multiple recruiters may submit candidates.

Retained Search: Pay upfront fee plus completion payment for executive or highly specialized searches. Ensures dedicated recruiter focus and exclusivity. Common for C-suite, medical director, and rare specialty positions.

Contract Staffing: Healthcare staffing firms provide temporary professionals while you recruit permanent hires. Immediate coverage with ongoing recruitment in parallel. Ideal for emergency gaps and seasonal surge.

Internal Process Optimization
Streamline internal processes to maximize HR team efficiency:

1. Technology Investment
Applicant tracking systems with automation capabilities:

  • Automated job posting distribution to multiple boards
  • Resume screening and ranking by qualifications
  • Interview scheduling and calendar integration
  • Candidate communication templates and workflows
  • Reporting and analytics on recruitment metrics

2. Hiring Manager Training
Inefficient hiring managers create HR bottlenecks. Training should cover:

  • Writing specific job descriptions that attract qualified candidates
  • Behavioral interviewing techniques improving candidate assessment
  • Making competitive offers quickly when talent is identified
  • Realistic preview of role and facility to manage expectations
  • Legal compliance in interviewing and selection

3. Standardized Workflows
Create checklists and templates for common recruitment activities:

  • Requisition approval processes with clear decision authority
  • Interview question banks by role type
  • Reference check templates and evaluation criteria
  • Offer letter templates with standard negotiation parameters
  • Onboarding checklists ensuring consistent new hire experience

4. Reduced Interview Cycles
Consolidate interview rounds without sacrificing quality:

  • Combined interviews with multiple stakeholders in single day
  • Panel interviews providing diverse perspectives efficiently
  • Video preliminary interviews saving candidate and interviewer time
  • Accelerated decision timelines preventing candidate loss to competitors

Common Implementation Pitfalls

Healthcare leaders frequently encounter these challenges when addressing staffing shortages. Awareness helps avoid predictable mistakes:

  1. Exclusive Focus on One Strategy
    Some facilities default entirely to either internal recruiting or temporary staffing, missing opportunities to blend approaches. Match each staffing need to the most appropriate strategy rather than forcing one-size-fits-all solutions.
  2. Insufficient Retention Investment
    Recruiting new staff while existing employees depart faster creates constant workforce instability. Parallel investment in retention programs often delivers better ROI than recruitment alone.
  3. Reactive Rather Than Predictive Planning
    Many facilities address vacancies only after they become critical, forcing expensive emergency solutions. Implement rolling workforce projections identifying needs 6-12 months ahead.
  4. Inadequate Onboarding for Temporary Staff
    Locum tenens and contract professionals receive abbreviated orientations, leading to slower productivity and quality concerns. Develop streamlined but comprehensive onboarding protocols.
  5. Underestimating APP Implementation Complexity
    Deploying APPs without appropriate supervision structures, physician buy-in, and workflow integration creates friction. Successful APP programs require multi-month planning and change management.
  6. Price-Only Vendor Selection
    Choosing staffing partners based solely on lowest rates often results in poor candidate quality and longer fill times. Evaluate total value including speed, quality, service, and relationship depth.

Future-Proofing Your Workforce Strategy

Healthcare staffing challenges will intensify over the next decade as demographic trends accelerate. The Bureau of Labor Statistics projects healthcare occupations will grow 13% from 2021 to 2031, significantly faster than average for all occupations, while educational program capacity expands more slowly.

Emerging Trends Shaping 2026 and Beyond

Technology-Enabled Care Models:

  • Telemedicine expansion allowing geographic flexibility for certain roles
  • AI-assisted documentation reducing administrative burden
  • Remote patient monitoring decreasing on-site staffing requirements for stable populations
  • Automation handling routine pharmacy, lab, and supply chain functions

Workforce Model Innovation:

  • Team-based care with expanded roles for medical assistants and community health workers
  • Hybrid positions combining traditionally separate specialties
  • Flexible employment models including part-time, job-sharing, and gig arrangements
  • Global talent pipelines with streamlined visa and credentialing processes

Compensation Evolution:

  • Performance-based pay tied to quality and efficiency outcomes
  • Enhanced benefits including student loan repayment and dependent care support
  • Geographic differentials reflecting true local market dynamics
  • Total rewards strategies emphasizing non-financial value

Educational Acceleration:

  • Competency-based training reducing time to practice for some roles
  • Apprenticeship models combining work and education
  • Technology-enabled skills training and simulation
  • Career advancement pathways for allied health to nursing to advanced practice

Facilities that proactively adapt strategies to leverage these trends will gain competitive advantage in attracting and retaining healthcare talent while those relying on traditional approaches face intensifying challenges.

Frequently Asked Questions About Solving Healthcare Staffing Shortages

What is the fastest way to fill critical healthcare staffing gaps in 2026?

Locum tenens staffing provides the fastest deployment for physician and advanced practice provider positions, typically placing qualified professionals within 7-10 days from need identification. For nursing and allied health roles, contract staffing firms can deliver candidates within 5-15 days. Both approaches cost significantly more than internal recruiting, locum tenens averages 1.5-2.0x base physician compensation while contract nursing runs 1.3-1.6x base rates, but prevent costly service disruptions, revenue loss from patient transfers, and burnout-driven turnover among existing staff forced into excessive overtime. Facilities should maintain relationships with 2-3 specialized staffing partners to ensure rapid response capabilities while simultaneously conducting traditional recruitment for permanent positions. The combination approach provides immediate coverage without sacrificing long-term workforce stability.

How can smaller facilities compete for healthcare talent against larger health systems?

Smaller facilities succeed by emphasizing differentiated value beyond pure compensation: community connection and lifestyle quality, broader clinical autonomy and skill variety, reduced bureaucracy enabling faster decision-making, and stronger work-life balance with less call burden. Competitive strategies include offering flexible scheduling with self-scheduling and compressed workweeks, providing robust student loan repayment assistance leveraging federal and state programs, creating hybrid employment models combining clinical work with leadership or teaching opportunities, and highlighting mission-driven culture with direct patient impact visibility. Geographic advantages matter, smaller communities often offer lower cost of living, safer neighborhoods, better schools, and outdoor recreation access. For physician recruitment, emphasize procedural variety and independence that larger systems restrict through narrow specialization. Consider APP team models allowing recruitment of NPs and PAs at more manageable compensation levels while providing excellent primary and specialty care. Partner with specialized recruiters who understand how to position small facility advantages to candidates seeking these specific attributes rather than competing head-to-head on compensation alone.

What metrics indicate whether our staffing strategy is actually working?

Track both leading indicators predicting future performance and lagging indicators confirming results achieved. Leading metrics include time-to-fill trending (are positions filling faster or slower than previous quarters), pipeline health (number of qualified active candidates per open requisition), offer acceptance rates (percentage accepting without extended negotiation), employee referrals (indicating staff confidence), and application volume per posted position. Lagging metrics include vacancy rate (unfilled FTEs as percentage of budgeted positions, target below 5%), turnover rate (departures as percentage of workforce, benchmark 15-18% for nursing, 6-8% for physicians), premium labor costs (overtime and temporary staffing as percentage of total labor, target below 10%), and new hire retention (percentage remaining at 90 days, 6 months, and 12 months). Quality indicators ensure sustainable solutions: patient satisfaction scores correlated with staffing adequacy, safety event rates, employee engagement scores, and staff burnout indicators like excessive overtime and PTO usage patterns. Establish baseline measurements, set quarterly improvement targets, and review monthly with leadership. Facilities showing improvement across multiple indicator categories demonstrate effective strategy execution, while those improving only isolated metrics may be creating new problems while solving old ones.

When should facilities use APPs instead of recruiting additional physicians?

Advanced practice providers work best in clinical scenarios with evidence-supported equivalent outcomes, particularly primary care chronic disease management, hospital medicine for lower-acuity patients, routine procedures after appropriate training, and specialty care follow-up visits. Research in JAMA and other peer-reviewed journals demonstrates APPs achieve quality outcomes comparable to physicians in these contexts while providing more cost-effective care delivery. Physician recruitment remains essential for complex diagnostic scenarios requiring extensive differential diagnosis, initial subspecialty consultations requiring specialist expertise, high-risk procedures beyond APP scope, and supervising/consulting roles in APP team models. The optimal approach frequently combines physicians and APPs in complementary team structures: APP-physician dyads where APP manages routine cases and physician handles complex patients, APP-led panels with physician consultation availability, and physician supervision of APP procedure teams. State practice authority significantly impacts deployment strategy, 24 states grant NPs full practice independence while 11 states require direct physician supervision, affecting both recruitment feasibility and care model design. Before implementing APP programs, facilities should assess whether clinical needs match appropriate APP scope, state regulations permit intended practice model, physician staff will support collaborative practice, and organization can provide necessary supervision infrastructure where required.

How do we prevent HR team burnout while managing multiple urgent staffing needs?

Prevent HR overload through strategic prioritization and appropriate use of external resources. Begin with workload assessment documenting time spent on recruitment activities, positions in active search, and average time-to-fill by role type. Apply prioritization framework considering business criticality (patient care impact if unfilled), probability of success (local candidate pool and compensation competitiveness), time sensitivity (urgency of need), and evaluation complexity (difficulty assessing candidates). High-criticality positions with low HR bandwidth or success probability should be outsourced to specialized healthcare recruiters, particularly physician and APP searches requiring national reach, high-volume seasonal needs, and specialized roles with limited candidate pools. Use locum tenens and contract staffing for immediate coverage while recruiting permanent hires, preventing crisis-driven reactive recruitment. Invest in technology including applicant tracking systems with automation, interview scheduling tools, and candidate communication platforms that reduce manual work. Train hiring managers on efficient practices: consolidated interview rounds, behavioral interviewing techniques, quick competitive offers, and realistic role previews. Implement standardized workflows with checklists, templates, and clear approval authority. Most importantly, phase implementation: deploy locum tenens for critical gaps (weeks 1-4), stabilize through priority permanent recruitment (months 2-4), then build strategic capabilities like APP programs and retention initiatives (months 5-12). This structured approach prevents attempting too many simultaneous changes while ensuring urgent needs receive immediate attention.

What should facilities budget for a comprehensive staffing strategy in 2026?

A balanced healthcare staffing budget allocates resources across multiple approaches based on facility size and shortage severity. For a typical 200-bed hospital, recommended distribution includes 70% for internal recruitment of permanent employees (base salaries, benefits, recruitment marketing, signing bonuses, relocation assistance), 8% for locum tenens coverage (emergency physician gaps, seasonal hospitalist surge, specialty coverage during vacancies), 12% for APP program development (NP and PA salaries, training, supervision infrastructure), and 10% for premium overtime and per diem coverage (existing staff overtime, PRN professionals for schedule gaps). Facilities in crisis may temporarily shift more budget to locum tenens and contract staffing, sometimes reaching 15-20% of labor budget, while building sustainable solutions. However, sustained reliance on temporary staffing above 12% of total labor costs indicates systemic problems requiring retention and recruitment infrastructure investment. Calculate total cost of workforce gaps including not just unfilled position salary but also lost revenue from service reductions, premium overtime for existing staff, quality impacts affecting reimbursement, and turnover costs from burnout-driven departures. When comprehensive analysis accounts for these factors, investment in diversified staffing strategies typically delivers positive ROI compared to continuing with inadequate coverage or excessive reliance on single approach. Smaller facilities should scale percentages proportionally while recognizing that specialized recruitment for hard-to-fill positions may represent higher percentage of total budget due to fixed costs in search processes.

Summarize at

Need help with staffing?
Get support from a dedicated recruiter who understands your facility’s clinical needs.
Request staffing support

Stay updated
on new opportunities

Stay in the loop with new opportunities, helpful resources, and support from our team.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.